Another point is mentioned in
historical texts concerning the execution of Hujr,
which shows 'A'ishah's deep political understanding.
She had declared: "By God, if Mu'awiyah had recognized
the heroic spirit, zeal and power of the people of
Kufah, he would never have dared to arrest and kill
Hujr and his friends. But the son of the liver-eater
woman(254) knows that fervent men of the Arabs no
longer exist in this world-; I swear to God that Hujr
and his friends possessed a high rank in their clear-sightedness,
heroism and courage.
The poet Lubayd has finely composed the following
lines about this matter:
"Those under whose auspices one could live,
Have departed this life, and lam left alone,
Amidst those who are as worthless as leprous skins!
They afford neither a benefit,
Nor is there any hope of their charity,
Their spokesman is cavilled at,
Even if he has caused no mischief." (255)
The death of Muhammad ibn Abi Bakr
O Mu'awiyah! Did
you not fear God in killing Hujr and his friends?
'A'ishah
The second factor of 'A'ishah's
disagreement with Mu'awiyah, was the tragic event
of the killing of her brother, Muhammad ibn Abi Bakr.
Ibn 'Abd al-Barr and Ibn al-Athir narrate: In the
year that Mu'awiyah had gone on a pilgrimage to Mecca,
he went to Medina presumably to visit the tomb of
the Prophet of God. During his stay in Medina, one
day he went to visit 'A'ishah. Her first words with
him were related to the execution of Hujr, about which
she said many things. The last answer of Mu'awiyah
was: "Leave Hujr and me alone to meet at the
threshold of our God "(256)
Some historians give greater details about this story
and say: After Mu'awiyah was permitted by 'A'ishah
to enter her house and sit down, she said to him:
"Mu'awiyah! How could