with 'A'ishah,
namely that, one day in 'A'ishah's presence the talk
led to the death of Dhu ath-Thadiyah at the hand of
Imam 'Ali. The narrator says: 'A'ishah said to me:
"If you visit Kufah bring me a letter of testimony
from the people who have witnessed this scene."
I went to Kufah and I chose ten people from each group
and collected their testimony in a letter and took
it to Medina for 'A'ishah. When she saw it, she said:
"May God damn 'Amr ibn al-'As! He claimed that
I have killed Dhu ath-Thadjyah in Egypt."(825)
After narrating this story, Ibn Kathir adds: Then
'A'ishah bent her head and wept bitterly. After she
stopped crying and calmed down, she said: "May
God bless 'Ali! He was always with God. What occurred
between me and him, was what often occurs between
women and their husbands' family."(326)
But as to why 'Amr ibn al-'As had made such a false
claim and intended to attribute the death of Dhu ath-Thadiyah
to himself, a reference to the narrations of the Prophet
clarifies the matter: Writers of tradition and historians
have quoted narrations from the Prophet in reproach
of Dhu ath-Thadiyah and in praise of his killer. In
this way 'Amr ibn al-'As intended to show the conformity
of his own praise with that of the Prophet.
Here the survey of 'A'ishah's life comes to an end,
and we return to the life of Mu'awiyah in order to
discover the motives for and factors of the fabrication
of traditions and narrations of that period, and find
out the great role of 'A'ishah in this process. For,
all our discussions and efforts are intended to recognize
the traditions, which are falsely attributed to the
Prophet in order to invert Islam. Therefore, without
such an analysis those lies cannot be distinguished
and criticized.